Saudi Arabia Is Building an Entire City in a Straight Line, for Some Reason

mohammed bin salman


  • Could the next big thing be a city built in a very long, narrow line?
  • Saudi Arabia’s idea sounds cool, but even a “hollow” circular city of this kind makes more logistical sense.
  • Cities grow based on what people need, like housing close to work or schools.

    Saudi Arabia has shared a wild idea to build a city without roads, where 1 million people will live in one long line along a core train track.

    You love mind-blowing ideas. So do we. Let’s nerd out over them together.

    Mohammed bin Salman bin Abdulaziz Al Saud, the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia, said in his Apple-like announcement that no one will live more than a “5-minute walk” from the services and shops they need, and the train line that anchors the line city will take just 20 minutes to travel its entire over 105-mile length.

    THE LINE, as bin Salman is calling the ambitious project, will “preserve 95 [percent] of nature … with zero cars, zero streets, and zero carbon emissions,” he said in a press release. The city will be powered by 100 percent clean energy and artificial intelligence, while “an estimated 90 [percent] of available data will be harnessed to enhance infrastructure capabilities far beyond the 1 [percent] typically utilized in existing smart cities.

    This content is imported from Twitter. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site.

    Technological traits aside, can bin Salman’s core concept—a 105-mile city built in a straight line—actually work? Let’s look at some math, game design, and even literature to consider the feasibility.

    This content is imported from {embed-name}. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site.

    If the city of Chicago, for example, were rearranged into one single line in this same way, at about the density of 1 million residents per 100 miles, the line would stretch almost to St. Louis—a distance of just under 300 miles. If the entire Chicagoland area were on such a line, it would reach to Jacksonville, Florida. This is an entirely new paradigm for building settlements for people.

    Or … is it? Does a line make sense for a city, and we’ve just never thought it through?

    First, the idea of one very long, narrow city does exist, at least in fiction. In Arrival author Ted Chiang’s story “Tower of Babylon“, the titular tower extends into the sky. “Were the tower to be laid down across the plain of Shinar, it would be two days journey to walk from one end to the other,” Chiang writes.

    That’s approximately 40 to 60 miles high—enough to nearly reach the Kármán Line, the generally recognized border of outer space. But this is still far shorter than our city “line.”
    In Chiang’s story, people who live along the tower’s height must climb over a month’s worth of stairs. It’s implied that this journey is almost always just one way.

    The Best Electric Scooters for Getting Around Your City

    Segway Ninebot MAX Electric Kick Scooter

    Best Overall

    Segway Ninebot MAX Electric Kick Scooter

    Segway amazon.com


    There’s a reason Segway’s Ninebot ES4 scooter tops every list. This option can reach up to 18.6 miles per hour and handle a 15-degree incline, so it’s suitable for flat roads and hills alike. Plus, it’s able to hold up to 220 pounds, making this a great option from every member in the family.  The LED display along the handlebar  makes it easy to keep tabs on your speed but if you want some more stats, you can use the accompanying app to check out riding stats, activate cruise control, and lock your scooter. Segway’s Ninebot ES4 scooter can travel up to 40 miles in a single charge. However, if you want to take a rest, you can trust the Anti-Locking braking system will ease your scooter to stillness.

    GOTRAX XR Ultra Electric Scooter

    Best Value

    GOTRAX XR Ultra Electric Scooter

    Gotrax amazon.com $399.99

    $359.99 (10% off)

    If you’re not ready to go all in on the Segway, GOTRAX XR Ultra is a great way to get a top-of-the-line scooter for a fraction of the price. Like the Segway, it offers a dual suspension stability system, a weight limit of 220 pounds, and an LED display that makes it easy to keep an eye on just how fast you’re going. It manages 17 miles on a single chargers making this great for scooter hobbyists. However, with a speed range of up to 15.5 miles per hour and a price difference of $400, you’ll be more than satisfied with this pick. 

    Xiaomi Mi Electric Scooter

    Best for Commuters

    Xiaomi Mi Electric Scooter

    Xiaomi amazon.com $599.00

    $499.99 (17% off)

    Xiaomi Mi electric scooter is designed to make commuting a breeze, tackling everything from the rolling hills of San Francisco to the concrete jungle of New York City with ease. Lightweight and coming in at just 26.9 pounds, this scooter is a great portable size. Thanks to the thick, 10-inch solid wheels (complete with shock absorption and anti-slip treads), you can even take this scooter off the beaten path with confidence.  Coupled with a 250w hub motor for stable power output, The Xiaomi Mi is set to deliver the smoothest morning ride. 

    Hover-1 Alpha Electric Kick Scooter

    Best for Beginners

    Hover-1 Alpha Electric Kick Scooter

    Hover-1 amazon.com


    If you want to take your scooter skills to the next level, Hover-1’s electric model won’t disappoint. With a spacious deck, the Hover-1 Alpha is perfect for novices who are just finding their footing on the open road. The rechargeable battery offers up to 12 miles of continuous use, so you can take a ride around  your neighborhood without losing steam. Not only can this option reach up to 117.4 miles per hour, but its rear wheel drive offers plenty of traction and control so you can become comfortable cruising along. 

    So what if we did lay the “tower” on its side to make one extraordinary line?

    The idea of being just 5 minutes from everything you need sounds good. It’s familiar to anyone who’s played a game like Pocket City or even Roller Coaster Tycoon, where the automated populations are happiest when they’re near their favorite facilities. But as Middle East Eye points out, it isn’t clear “how or why a city built in a straight line made it easier for people to walk to their desired destinations compared to a conventionally shaped city.”

    It also isn’t clear why a single line is better than a circular train line with a ring of human settlement surrounding it. Yes, being 20 minutes from the other side of town is good, but residents of a “wagon wheel” would never be further than just 10 minutes away, and trains could run freely in one direction continuously. The amount of area surrounding the train line would still be the same for people seeking to build homes and businesses.

    pictured are two Pictured are two “cities” of the same length. The longest trip in a linear city is the full length. The longest trip around a circle is just 10 minutes, the furthest point away that you could reach.

    Caroline Delbert

    Does a “hollow” shape like this—a line or an empty circle—make more sense than how our cities are now, packed solid and sprawling? Presumably, this eliminates the need for roads by simply limiting the depth to which the population can settle along a particular axis. If people never take more than a 5-minute walk from the train, they’ll never need a road.

    But there are structural problems with this, like the fact that highways carry more overland cargo than people. People won’t want to carry cargo onto or off of a train, even if it’s “only” to their shops 5 minutes away. How will they ever pack up and move? How will disabled people navigate the city?

    Residents already do impromptu geometry when they decide where to live. People who can withstand a longer commute can live farther away from city centers, in housing that likely costs less. Others simply must withstand the commute because they can’t afford to live closer.

    Commuting Essentials

    Outdoor Research Essential Face Mask Kit

    Outdoor Research Essential Face Mask Kit

    Bern Allston Bike Helmet

    Bern Allston Bike Helmet



    RockyMounts Hendrix Compact Folding Bicycle Lock

    RockyMounts Hendrix Compact Folding Bicycle Lock

    RockyMounts amazon.com


    Light & Motion Urban 500 Bike Headlight

    Light & Motion Urban 500 Bike Headlight

    In a linear city with no roads, it’s easy to imagine “front-row” housing taking a hugely premium price, while people must somehow lug goods to and from their more affordable homes in the next rows.

    Over 105 miles long sounds like a lot, but for a million people, that’s still about two people per foot of length. Able-bodied people might prefer to build even more rows that are a longer walk away, but closer to the place where they work, causing buildup around places that have the most business and service activity. Maybe it makes sense to extend a small train line to the end of that new area of settlement. And … now we’re just building a regular city. 🤷‍️

    This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. You may be able to find more information about this and similar content at piano.io

    Saudi Arabia Is Building an Entire City in a Straight Line, for Some Reason

    More Story on Source:

    * Source→ *


    Publication author

    offline 2 weeks

    SFi Official

    Comments: 0Publics: 1356Registration: 11-03-2021